Library/Regulatory
Regulatory · 7 min

Canada softwood: USMCA panel requests on 2024 reviews

Requests filed Nov 18, 2026. Complaints Dec 18; appearances Jan 4, 2027. October 2026 deposit rates stay unless changed. USTR roster apps due Dec 4.

Cover illustration: Canada softwood: USMCA panel requests on 2024 reviews

Two Requests for Panel Review were filed November 18, 2026 with the U.S. Section of the USMCA Secretariat against Commerce's October 19, 2026 final results for softwood lumber from Canada: the 2024 CVD administrative review (91 FR 66,092) and the 2024 AD administrative review with partial rescission and no-shipments determination (91 FR 66,087). The notices (FR Docs. 2026-23794 CVD; 2026-23790 AD) were filed for Federal Register public inspection on November 20, 2026 and are scheduled for publication on November 23, 2026. Separately, the NAFTA Article 1904 softwood lumber AD investigation panel affirmed Commerce's Second Redetermination on Remand (FR Doc. 2026-23082; 91 FR 73204, November 13, 2026), and the companion CVD investigation panel review was completed with panelists discharged effective November 19, 2026 (FR Doc. 2026-23773). USTR is also soliciting applications for the U.S. Chapter 10 binational panel roster for April 1, 2027 through March 31, 2028 (FR Doc. 2026-23412; 91 FR 74270, November 18, 2026; docket USTR-2026-0562).

USMCA Complaints on the 2024 softwood finals are due December 18, 2026. Cash deposit rates from the October 2026 finals stay in effect unless and until changed.

USMCA panel requests on the 2024 reviews

USMCA Article 10.12 lets a Party or interested person obtain binational panel review of a final AD or CVD determination of one USMCA Party covering products of another. A panel applies the importing Party's domestic law and the standard of review a domestic court would use, and issues a binding Panel Decision. The USMCA Rules of Procedure for Article 10.12 set the Complaint and appearance clocks after the first Request for Panel Review (see the Article 10.12 Rules).

CVD case USA-CDA-2026-10.12-01 challenges the CVD 2024 final results. AD case USA-CDA-2026-10.12-02 challenges the AD 2024 final results. On each matter, two Requests for Panel Review were filed November 18, 2026.

On the CVD request, one group is led by the Government of Canada and the governments of Alberta, British Columbia, New Brunswick, Ontario, and Québec; the Alberta Softwood Lumber Trade Council and British Columbia Lumber Trade Council; and producers including Canfor Corporation, Interfor Corporation, Interfor Sales & Marketing Ltd., EACOM Timber Corporation, Chaleur Forest Products Inc., Chaleur Forest Products LP, J.D. Irving, Limited, Tolko Marketing and Sales Ltd. and Tolko Industries Ltd., Gilbert Smith Forest Products, and West Fraser Mills Ltd. A second CVD request was filed for Resolute FP Canada Inc., the Conseil de l'industrie forestière du Québec, the Ontario Forest Industries Association and each association's individual members listed in Attachment A (collectively "Central Canada"), Plaster Rock Lumber Corporation, and CHAP Alliance Inc.

On the AD request, one group is Central Canada, Plaster Rock Lumber Corporation, and CHAP Alliance Inc. The other is the Government of Canada and the governments of Alberta, British Columbia, Ontario, and Québec; the Alberta and B.C. lumber trade councils; Canfor Corporation, Canadian Forest Products Ltd., Canfor Wood Products Marketing Ltd., Canfor Fox Creek Ltd., Canfor Whitecourt Ltd., Fontaine Inc., Interfor Corporation, Interfor Sales & Marketing Ltd., EACOM Timber Corporation, Chaleur Forest Products Inc., Chaleur Forest Products LP, J.D. Irving, Limited, Tolko Marketing and Sales Ltd. and Tolko Industries Ltd., Gilbert Smith Forest Products, and West Fraser Mills Ltd.

Action · Case · Date / deadline
CVD Requests for Panel Review · USA-CDA-2026-10.12-01 · filed Nov 18, 2026 (challenging 91 FR 66,092)
AD Requests for Panel Review · USA-CDA-2026-10.12-02 · filed Nov 18, 2026 (challenging 91 FR 66,087)
Complaints (Rule 44) · both USMCA reviews · due Dec 18, 2026 (30 days after first request)
Notices of Appearance (Rule 45) · both USMCA reviews · due Jan 4, 2027 (45 days after first request)
NAFTA AD panel decision · USA-CDA-2017-1904-03 · affirmed Second Redetermination on Remand Nov 6, 2026 (91 FR 73204)
NAFTA CVD panel completion · USA-CDA-2017-1904-02 · completed; panelists discharged effective Nov 19, 2026
USTR Chapter 10 roster applications · USTR-2026-0562 · due Dec 4, 2026 (roster Apr 1, 2027-Mar 31, 2028)

Under the Rules, panel review is limited to allegations of error of fact or law (including jurisdictional challenges) set out in the Complaints, plus procedural and substantive defenses raised in the review. The October 2026 deposit rates from those finals remain the operative cash deposits unless and until Commerce or a later panel step changes them. An earlier Library item covers the Canada softwood lumber AD/CVD 2024 review finals being challenged.

NAFTA Chapter 19 softwood panels wind down

On November 6, 2026, the binational panel in USA-CDA-2017-1904-03 (Certain Softwood Lumber Products from Canada: Final Affirmative Less Than Fair Value Determination) affirmed Commerce's Second Redetermination on Remand (FR Doc. 2026-23082; 91 FR 73204). Separately, the CVD investigation panel review USA-CDA-2017-1904-02 was completed and the panelists were discharged from their duties effective November 19, 2026 (FR Doc. 2026-23773). Earlier Library items cover the CVD panel's affirmance of the second remand and the final panel action with amended rates.

USTR Chapter 10 roster for 2027-2028

USTR invites applications for inclusion on the U.S. Chapter 10 binational panel roster for April 1, 2027 through March 31, 2028. Applications are due December 4, 2026 via Regulations.gov docket USTR-2026-0562. Annex 10-B.1 calls for a roster of at least 75 individuals, with each Party selecting at least 25. Each review uses a five-person panel; a majority must be lawyers in good standing, and the chair must be a lawyer. Panels apply the importing Party's domestic AD/CVD law and standard of review; in limited circumstances, a three-member extraordinary challenge committee may be drawn from a separate roster of 15 current or former judges. U.S. selection procedures are in 19 U.S.C. 4582.

Action items

  • Track USA-CDA-2026-10.12-01 (CVD) and USA-CDA-2026-10.12-02 (AD) for Complaints due December 18, 2026 and Notices of Appearance due January 4, 2027.
  • Keep applying the October 19, 2026 final cash deposit rates unless and until Commerce publishes a change.
  • Counsel or potential panelists: USTR roster applications for April 1, 2027 through March 31, 2028 are due December 4, 2026 on docket USTR-2026-0562.
  • Importers of Canadian softwood should monitor ACCESS and Secretariat notices; panel review does not, by itself, rewrite deposit instructions.
Drawback note

Antidumping and countervailing duties generally cannot be recovered through drawback. See AD/CVD drawback exclusion. Panel review does not change that rule.

Key takeaways
  • USMCA Requests for Panel Review filed Nov 18, 2026 against Canada softwood CVD (USA-CDA-2026-10.12-01; 91 FR 66,092) and AD (USA-CDA-2026-10.12-02; 91 FR 66,087) 2024 finals. FR Docs. 2026-23794 and 2026-23790: public inspection Nov 20; scheduled FR publication Nov 23, 2026.
  • Complaints due Dec 18, 2026; Notices of Appearance due Jan 4, 2027. Review limited to Complaint allegations of error of fact or law plus defenses raised.
  • NAFTA AD panel USA-CDA-2017-1904-03 affirmed Commerce's Second Redetermination on Remand Nov 6, 2026 (91 FR 73204). CVD panel USA-CDA-2017-1904-02 completed; panelists discharged effective Nov 19, 2026.
  • USTR Chapter 10 roster applications for Apr 1, 2027-Mar 31, 2028 due Dec 4, 2026 (USTR-2026-0562). Roster at least 75; five-person panels; majority lawyers; chair a lawyer.
  • October 2026 final deposit rates stay in effect unless and until changed. AD/CVD generally cannot be recovered as drawback.
Primary sources
  1. USMCA Article 10.12: Notice of Request for Panel Review (CVD 2024 softwood lumber) · USMCA Secretariat / Federal Register
  2. Public inspection PDF: FR Doc. 2026-23794 · Federal Register
  3. USMCA Article 10.12: Notice of Requests for Panel Review (AD 2024 softwood lumber) · USMCA Secretariat / Federal Register
  4. Public inspection PDF: FR Doc. 2026-23790 · Federal Register
  5. NAFTA Article 1904: Notice of Completion of Panel Review (CVD investigation) · NAFTA Secretariat / Federal Register
  6. Public inspection PDF: FR Doc. 2026-23773 · Federal Register
  7. NAFTA Article 1904: Notice of Panel Decision (AD LTFV Second Redetermination) · NAFTA Secretariat / Federal Register
  8. Applications for Inclusion on the Binational Panels Roster Under the USMCA · USTR / Federal Register
  9. USTR-2026-0562 · Regulations.gov
  10. USMCA Rules of Procedure for Article 10.12 (Binational Panel Reviews) · USMCA Secretariat
  11. 19 U.S.C. 4582 · Legal Information Institute
  12. ACCESS · Commerce
DA
DrawbackAI Team
We build software for the US duty drawback program — so the refund isn't reserved for billion-dollar importers and the firms that charge 30% to find it.

This article is for general information and is not legal or tax advice. Drawback eligibility depends on your specific facts, and final refunds are determined by CBP at liquidation. Consult a licensed customs broker or attorney for your situation.

Find out what you're owed.

Upload your imports and exports. Get a defensible estimate in under 10 minutes. No card required.

Get free estimate